The Performers….
They are often met with pieces that aren’t ready for performance. The composers also have yet to learn how to express their intent in the rehearsals (after all, they are students as well). The performers, as well as the composers, are being judged at the performance. How might a performer feel if they are constantly struggling to play the piece? If they are continuously feeling humiliated, wouldn’t that effect they’re response to a composer asking them to perform a new piece in the future?
In an earlier post, I wrote…
“What if they play your piece at the concert and it goes very well. The audience likes it and the performers love playing it. Your success and future performances of the piece are now a foregone conclusion……… Only… it never happens. The cello player, after performing your piece, remarks that it’s one of the best new pieces he or she has ever played, perhaps the best. The trio has future performance engagements. He or she talks about programming your piece……. But it never happens. Why?”
Performers with vast 19th century repertoires program Beethoven and Brahms because they think that’s what their audiences want to hear. Are they right? Certainly there is a portion of the population that will buy tickets because they recognize those names. But do they actually like the pieces being played? Of course, some do. But a portion of the audience will say that they like the pieces even if they don’t because to say they don’t like a piece by Beethoven or Brahms is to be deemed unsophisticated. Performers are getting insincere feedback from a certain, and I would say large, portion of the audience. If you have any doubts about this, play an unfamiliar piece of music and say it’s by Aaron Copland. Play that same piece for a different audience (but similar demographic) and say it’s by a current student at generic state university. Will the reactions be the same? I doubt it.
Performers are being told by their professors and audiences that their economic livelihood is dependent on the 19th century repertoire. They believe it, understandably, even in the face of economic realities that say otherwise. Ensembles that focus on the traditional repertoire are struggling to survive. Doesn’t that struggle incentivize other options. A colleague of mine once said, referring to performers who solely perform 19th century repertoire, that “they are museum curators,” not apart of a living and breathing art. Although I don’t agree with this entirely, it’s a catchy quote that contains some truth.